TY - UNPB
T1 - The Anatomy of a Broken Promise: Why Trust Restoration Is a Behavioral Problem, Not a Communications One
AU - LeMay, Stephen Arthur
AU - Karimova, Guli-Sanam
PY - 2026
Y1 - 2026
N2 - Public confidence in institutions has fallen to historic lows, and leaders routinely treat the problem as one of communication—a messaging failure to be repaired with campaigns and reassurance. Existing trust-repair scholarship, meanwhile, concentrates on apology, explanation, compensation, and structural control. We argue that many of the most damaging institutional trust failures are behavioral rather than communicative, and that restoration therefore requires sustained behavioral commitments embedded in governance rather than a response to a violation. An institution violates an implicit promise to those who depend on it and then conceals the violation, and the concealment often does more damage than the original breach. We distinguish three kinds of implicit promise—operational, ethical, and institutional—corresponding to the three conditions a stakeholder must believe before extending trust, and examine a characteristic failure of each in Theranos, Equifax, and Lehman Brothers. From cross-case comparison we derive the Three Commitments Model of Trust Restoration: reveal the truth before exposure forces it, invite the dissent that lets governance see its own blind spots, and pay the cost of stated values in the moments when honoring them hurts. Each case is explained by the absence of one commitment; Johnson & Johnson's 1982 Tylenol recall displays all three. For each commitment we offer a concrete managerial tool. We explain why communication-centered remedies disappoint and reframe the leader's central question toward what the institution will actually do when its own comfort and its obligations to stakeholders diverge.
AB - Public confidence in institutions has fallen to historic lows, and leaders routinely treat the problem as one of communication—a messaging failure to be repaired with campaigns and reassurance. Existing trust-repair scholarship, meanwhile, concentrates on apology, explanation, compensation, and structural control. We argue that many of the most damaging institutional trust failures are behavioral rather than communicative, and that restoration therefore requires sustained behavioral commitments embedded in governance rather than a response to a violation. An institution violates an implicit promise to those who depend on it and then conceals the violation, and the concealment often does more damage than the original breach. We distinguish three kinds of implicit promise—operational, ethical, and institutional—corresponding to the three conditions a stakeholder must believe before extending trust, and examine a characteristic failure of each in Theranos, Equifax, and Lehman Brothers. From cross-case comparison we derive the Three Commitments Model of Trust Restoration: reveal the truth before exposure forces it, invite the dissent that lets governance see its own blind spots, and pay the cost of stated values in the moments when honoring them hurts. Each case is explained by the absence of one commitment; Johnson & Johnson's 1982 Tylenol recall displays all three. For each commitment we offer a concrete managerial tool. We explain why communication-centered remedies disappoint and reframe the leader's central question toward what the institution will actually do when its own comfort and its obligations to stakeholders diverge.
U2 - 10.2139/ssrn.7153983
DO - 10.2139/ssrn.7153983
M3 - Working Paper/Preprint
BT - The Anatomy of a Broken Promise: Why Trust Restoration Is a Behavioral Problem, Not a Communications One
ER -