Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Understanding Agency within Democratic Governance Structures

Activity: Talk or presentation › Science to science

Description

Democratic and participatory governance structures have long been an aspiration for many alternative organizations. Yet, numerous empirical challenges have been observed, often resulting in the abandonment of utopian projects or a dilution of democratic ideals (Shanahan, 2025). As democratic governance remains an ideal nevertheless (King & Griffin, 2019), we explore how nonprofit organizations can establish governance structures that are sustainably democratic and participatory, while navigating the risks of mission drift (or goal degeneration), organizational paralysis, insulation, marketization, and oligarchization.
We use the field of communal housing as an exemplary case to study participatory governance structures. Communal housing projects are trying to organize their neighborhoods collectively, democratizing everyday life, as a reaction to the permanent conflict between housing as a home and housing as real estate (Marcuse & Madden, 2024). Housing projects present an ideal case to investigate degenerations and regenerations of democratic governance structures, as democratic ideals are at the center of housing projects’ mission. Also, the aspiration to democratize everyday life gave birth to various radical experiments with participatory governance structures, some of which have been going on for more than 40 years. Lastly, the full immersion of the members of housing projects as compared to initiatives that form only one aspect of their members’ life makes the psychological dynamics more intense and thus easier to observe.
Drawing from problem-centered interviews with both communal housing experts and residents, conducted between fall 2024 and fall 2025 in the research project ‘Communal Housing as a Social Praxis of future-oriented communalization’ at the University of Applied Sciences Fulda, we build a comparative analysis of democratic governance structures. Specifically, we aim at identifying the degenerations to the high ideals of participatory governance. To this end, we develop a preliminary conceptual typology linking the psychological dynamics among the members to the organizational level degenerations of democracy. The differentiation of critical psychology’s concept between restricted and generalized agency (Holzkamp, 1990) is used to conceptualize the individuals perceived scope of agency within the organization, linking it to the (non-)functioning of the horizontal governance. This often overseen psychological dimension whether or not one’s own action is experienced to make a difference is essential to members’ sustained engagement in participatory governance.
Building on this foundation, we aim to identify practices—such as the concept of impure critical performativity as discussed by Shanahan (2025), insights from Cornforth (1995) or Griffin et al. (2022)—that members employ to counteract these degenerations. Our focus is on navigating the persistent, often unresolvable tensions that arise from internal contradictions within the organization. With our findings we attempt to complement the literature on degenerations of horizontal governance structures from organizational studies with the perspectives of critical psychology.
Period14 Jul 2026
Event title17th International ISTR Conference: Strengthening the Foundations of the Third Sector
Event typeConference
LocationLissabon, PortugalShow on map
Degree of RecognitionInternational